Skip to content
FIELD NOTES // THE CAMP IS OPENSURVIVING, NOT SUFFERING

Survivor Reflection: When Being a Fan Isn’t Enough

I’ve noticed quite a few people talking about Elon Musk over the past couple of days, particularly following his recent comments about the MAGA movement.

During the 2024 American presidential election campaign, Musk was one of Donald Trump’s most prominent supporters. He attended rallies, contributed substantial amounts of money to Republican political efforts and even described himself as “Dark MAGA” during a rally in Butler, Pennsylvania.

Fast-forward to 18 November 2026, and the situation looks rather different. During an appearance at the New York Times DealBook Summit, Musk stated that he wasn’t MAGA and questioned what the term actually meant.

As the Associated Press reported, he explained that he did not identify with the label if it meant uncritical loyalty to Republican Party policies. He also expressed regret about the hundreds of millions of dollars he’d spent supporting Republican candidates during the 2026 midterm elections. TechCrunch also covered his remarks.

Naturally, people have been commenting on the contrast between his previous enthusiasm and his more recent statements. Now, people are allowed to change their political opinions. They can become disillusioned with movements they previously supported, disagree with particular policies or simply reconsider where they stand. There’s nothing inherently wrong with that.

But watching the reaction to Musk’s comments got me thinking about something else. I’ve occasionally wondered whether Musk has a particularly strong desire to be liked by the people around him. Or perhaps being liked isn’t quite the right description. Maybe it’s more about recognition and the way he presents his achievements.

I can’t establish what motivates him personally, and I wouldn’t pretend otherwise. But the more I thought about it, the more I remembered various incidents involving his public image. And, strangely enough, gaming seems like a reasonable place to start.

Apparently, He Was One of the Best Quake Players

Back in November 2023, Musk appeared on the Lex Fridman Podcast, where he discussed his gaming history. During the conversation, Musk claimed that he’d once been among the world’s best Quake players.

He also described participating in what he believed was one of the first paid esports tournaments in the United States. According to Musk, his four-player team finished second. He claimed they might have won if their strongest player’s computer hadn’t crashed during the competition.

Now, competitive gaming in the 1990s was considerably different from what we recognise today. Records weren’t always comprehensive, and some early tournament results are difficult to verify. So I wouldn’t automatically dismiss his tournament story.

But there’s another perspective worth considering. Dennis “Thresh” Fong, one of the most accomplished competitive Quake players of that era, actually remembered playing on the same servers as Musk.

Fong was a pioneer of professional gaming, famously winning John Carmack’s Ferrari at the 1997 Red Annihilation tournament. And when asked about Musk’s abilities, his assessment was rather different.

As discussed in PC Gamer’s reporting, Fong confirmed that Musk genuinely participated in the early Quake community. However, he didn’t remember Musk as being particularly good at the game.

And that’s what makes the story interesting. Fong wasn’t accusing Musk of inventing his entire gaming history. Quite the opposite. He confirmed that Musk was a genuine player who had been involved in that early competitive scene.

Musk didn’t need to be one of the world’s best players to have an interesting history with Quake. He was there. He played the game. He shared servers with people who would help establish professional gaming. That’s already something worth talking about.

So why introduce the claim about being among the best? Perhaps Musk genuinely remembers his abilities differently. Memories can become exaggerated over time, particularly when we’re talking about events from decades ago. But the difference between the accounts raises an interesting question: why wouldn’t simply being part of that early gaming community be enough?

Diablo IV and Path of Exile 2

The Quake story wasn’t the last time Musk attracted attention over his gaming abilities.

In November 2024, during an appearance on Joe Rogan’s podcast, he claimed to be among the world’s top twenty Diablo IV players. And to be fair, there was evidence supporting that claim.

As Forbes reported, Musk had reached nineteenth place on the Helltides leaderboard for completing the game’s difficult Pit 150 challenge. That’s a genuine leaderboard result, and completing difficult endgame content quickly isn’t something every player can do.

However, the ranking covered a particular activity on a community-maintained leaderboard. It wasn’t a comprehensive assessment of every Diablo IV player in the world. There’s a difference between being highly ranked in one challenge and being one of the best players across an entire game.

Then, in January 2025, Musk became involved in another controversy, this time surrounding Path of Exile 2. He’d been sharing his progress with a highly ranked Hardcore character, but experienced players began questioning his abilities after watching him livestream.

Viewers noticed mistakes and apparent gaps in his understanding of mechanics that somebody playing at that level would normally be expected to know. Of course, even experienced players make mistakes. A few questionable decisions during a livestream aren’t proof that somebody doesn’t understand a game.

But the controversy developed further. YouTuber NikoWrex subsequently shared messages from a conversation with Musk, reportedly with his permission. Musk reposted the video containing those messages, although The Guardian reported that it could not independently authenticate the transcript.

The exchange indicated that Musk had used account boosting, allowing other people to progress his characters. He defended account sharing as necessary to compete with some other highly ranked players.

The Washington Post also investigated the controversy, reporting on the questions surrounding his gaming achievements. The messages indicated that other people had helped advance his accounts, though they did not clearly establish the exact payment arrangements.

It’s also worth including Musk’s response: he said he had never taken full credit for levelling his characters. Grimes separately defended his Diablo IV abilities, saying she had personally witnessed his accomplishments in the game.

And that’s an important distinction. Having a highly ranked character isn’t necessarily the same as personally achieving everything required to reach that position.

I can understand why someone managing several major companies might struggle to dedicate the time required to compete at the highest levels of games like Path of Exile 2. These games can demand an extraordinary amount of time. But there’s nothing wrong with being unable to dedicate that time.

Musk could simply enjoy the game, stream himself playing it and occasionally struggle with difficult encounters. That’s what gaming looks like for most of us.

I’ve made plenty of mistakes in games over the years. Some of them have been rather obvious in hindsight. Sometimes I learn from them, and sometimes I repeat exactly the same mistake. It happens.

I wouldn’t want somebody else completing everything on my behalf and then presenting the results as though I’d personally achieved them. What would be the point? For me, the experience is part of the enjoyment, including the parts that don’t go particularly well.

And that’s what I find interesting about the controversy. Musk already had a genuine history with gaming. Nobody needed him to prove he was an elite player. Yet once again, the discussion became about rankings, exceptional ability and how much of the achievement was actually his.

His Daughter Has Made a Similar Observation

There’s another perspective worth considering, and it comes from someone who has known Musk considerably better than most of the people discussing his gaming history: his daughter, Vivian Jenna Wilson.

Wilson has been outspoken about her father, particularly following comments he made about her gender identity in July 2024. The two are estranged, and their relationship has clearly been difficult. I don’t intend to turn this reflection into an examination of their family history.

But I don’t think her perspective should be ignored simply because their relationship has broken down. She has first-hand experiences that are relevant to some of the incidents we’re discussing. And interestingly, she has made an observation remarkably similar to the one that started this reflection.

In July 2024, while responding to Musk’s public statements about her, Wilson accused him of being:

“desperate for attention and validation”

Her comments were subsequently discussed in her March 2025 interview with Teen Vogue.

Now, that’s Wilson’s assessment of her father, not an independently established explanation of his motivations. It also came during a deeply personal public disagreement, which is relevant context.

But I find it interesting that someone who knew him personally had expressed something so similar to what I’d been wondering while observing his public behaviour.

And then there’s what she said about gaming. During a March 2025 appearance on Hasan Piker’s livestream, Wilson recalled playing Overwatch with Musk when she was around twelve.

According to Wilson, Musk was a Bronze-ranked Torbjörn player, while she and her twin were ranked higher. She claimed that he regularly wanted them to join his competitive matches and suspected he wanted their assistance improving his results.

As PC Gamer reported, Wilson was rather direct in her assessment of his gaming abilities.

There’s absolutely nothing wrong with being Bronze. Not everyone can be Diamond, Master or Grandmaster. That’s rather the point of a competitive ranking system.

And there’s nothing wrong with wanting to play video games with your children, either. Even wanting stronger teammates doesn’t automatically mean somebody is misrepresenting their abilities.

But Wilson’s recollection adds another perspective to the discussion, particularly when placed alongside the later account-boosting controversy. Unlike people watching Musk’s livestreams, she was describing games she said she’d personally played with him.

Her account doesn’t independently establish his ability in other games, but it does deserve consideration. And it brings me back to something I’ve never particularly understood about gaming communities: why does being good at a game sometimes seem more important than simply enjoying it?

Even Cyberpunk 2077 Became Part of the Story

There’s another gaming incident worth mentioning, although this one has nothing to do with leaderboards.

In Walter Isaacson’s 2023 biography of Musk, he described an incident during the development of Cyberpunk 2077. According to Isaacson, Musk interrupted a recording session involving Grimes, who voiced the character Lizzy Wizzy, and insisted that the developers give him a cameo appearance. The account also described Musk arriving with an antique firearm. The incident was covered by Kotaku.

Now, that account comes from Isaacson’s biography, rather than an independently released recording of the encounter. And despite speculation that a background character in Cyberpunk 2077 resembled Musk, a senior CD Projekt Red developer subsequently denied that the character was intended to represent him. PC Gamer reported on that denial.

So I’m not suggesting Musk actually appeared in the game.

But the reported request is interesting. Musk was already internationally recognised for his involvement in technology. His companies were working in areas that had similarities to some of the futuristic concepts explored in Cyberpunk 2077.

Perhaps he simply thought a cameo would be entertaining. That’s entirely possible, and there’s nothing inherently wrong with wanting to appear in a game. But it’s another occasion where public recognition became part of a story involving him. Not recognition for playing the game particularly well this time, but recognition within the game itself.

When Attention Becomes the Story

There’s one incident I think is particularly relevant to my original observation. And it involves Twitter, now known as X.

In February 2023, technology publication Platformer published an investigation into how Musk’s posts were being promoted on Twitter. The story followed that year’s Super Bowl.

Musk had posted his support for the Philadelphia Eagles, but his post received considerably fewer impressions than one from then-President Joe Biden.

According to Platformer’s investigation, which drew on interviews and internal documents, Twitter engineers subsequently implemented changes designed to increase the visibility of Musk’s posts. The report described around eighty engineers becoming involved and a multiplier of 1,000 being applied to the ranking score of Musk’s tweets. That was not a claim that his actual views increased a thousandfold.

That’s a striking allegation. At the time, Musk already owned Twitter. He had an enormous following, and his posts regularly attracted considerable attention. Yet, according to the reporting, the performance of one particular post prompted changes intended to increase that attention further.

Researchers associated with Queensland University of Technology subsequently examined data from the platform. Their analysis, published by the ARC Centre of Excellence for Automated Decision-Making and Society, found changes in impressions consistent with elements of Platformer’s reporting.

However, those observations didn’t independently establish every detail of the alleged internal instructions. Platformer also reported that engineers had identified possible technical reasons for Musk’s posts receiving fewer impressions than expected.

And Musk disputed the accusations. As Fortune reported, he rejected the claim that his posts had been promoted beyond their usual levels and cited a separate software bug affecting the prominence of replies. The journalists stood by their reporting.

So there is a distinction between the reported internal events, the independently observed changes in engagement and Musk’s denial.

But the controversy itself raises an interesting question. What happens when somebody already has one of the largest audiences on a social media platform, yet the amount of attention they’re receiving becomes a source of dispute?

Social media has made it remarkably easy to measure attention. Followers, likes, views, reposts and engagement statistics provide a constant stream of numbers telling people how much interest they’re attracting.

But having a large audience and feeling sufficiently recognised by that audience aren’t necessarily the same thing. And there’s another distinction worth making.

Being noticed isn’t the same as being liked. A post might receive millions of views because people agree with it, disagree with it or simply find it controversial. High engagement doesn’t automatically translate into admiration.

Which makes the Twitter incident particularly interesting alongside the gaming controversies. The gaming stories concern recognition for achievement. The Twitter reporting concerns visibility itself. And perhaps those are two different sides of the same broader discussion.

Being Important, or Being Seen as Important?

There’s one smaller example that I think fits here, although I wouldn’t give it too much significance on its own.

In March 2021, Tesla formally changed Musk’s corporate title to “Technoking of Tesla”. The company’s chief financial officer, Zach Kirkhorn, simultaneously received the title “Master of Coin”. Both retained their executive positions.

This wasn’t simply an internet nickname. Tesla announced the changes in an official filing with the US Securities and Exchange Commission.

Now, I suspect there’s a considerable element of humour and corporate branding involved in those titles. And that’s fine. But it illustrates Musk’s willingness to cultivate an unconventional public identity.

Being Tesla’s chief executive was already a significant position. Technoking was a rather more distinctive way of presenting it. That doesn’t prove anything about his need for approval.

But it leads into something I’ve been considering throughout this reflection. There’s a difference between achieving something and wanting that achievement to be recognised in a particular way.

Someone can enjoy a game without being among its best players. They can support a political movement without becoming one of its leading representatives. They can build a successful business without adopting an unconventional title. And they can participate in a community without needing to be recognised as an exceptional member of it.

None of those things necessarily makes their involvement any less genuine. But public recognition can become complicated when it’s tied closely to how someone presents themselves. And I think that’s what makes these incidents worth examining together.

Back to MAGA

Which brings me back to the situation that sent me down this route in the first place.

In October 2024, Musk was publicly embracing the MAGA movement. By November 2026, he was explaining that he didn’t identify with the label, at least not if it meant unquestioning loyalty to Republican policies.

The contrast has attracted attention, particularly given the extent of his previous political involvement and financial contributions.

But it’s important not to force the gaming comparisons further than they reasonably go. A competitive gaming ranking is something that can be measured, even if people disagree about what that ranking actually represents.

Political beliefs are different. They can change in response to events, disagreements, experiences and personal priorities. Musk’s recent remarks don’t automatically establish that his earlier political support was insincere. Nor do they establish that his current explanation is insincere.

We can examine the difference between his public statements without knowing precisely what prompted it.

With Quake, Musk’s account of his abilities differed from that of a prominent contemporary player. With Diablo IV and Path of Exile 2, there were questions about the relationship between rankings and personal achievement.

With Cyberpunk 2077, his biographer described a request to appear within a fictional world. With Twitter, journalists reported efforts to increase his visibility, while Musk disputed the claims.

His daughter has also publicly accused him of seeking attention and validation, drawing on her own experiences with him. And now there’s the contrast between his enthusiastic embrace of MAGA and his more recent distancing from the label.

These incidents don’t all mean the same thing, and none provides a definitive explanation of Musk’s private motivations. But together, they raise questions about public identity, achievement and recognition. Which is what interested me in the first place.

Is Being Liked the Same as Being Admired?

I started this reflection wondering whether Elon Musk has a particularly strong desire to be liked. His daughter has expressed something similar, although her assessment remains her own.

But the more I considered the examples, the more I realised that being liked, being admired and being noticed are three different things.

Being liked doesn’t require exceptional ability. You can be an average player, make mistakes and still be a valued member of a gaming community.

Admiration often involves something different. People admire achievements, skill, influence and success. And attention doesn’t necessarily require either of those things. Someone can attract an enormous audience without everybody in that audience liking or admiring them.

That’s particularly relevant in an age where public figures can measure their visibility through social media statistics.

I can’t say which, if any, of those forms of recognition explains Musk’s behaviour. But I do find it interesting that someone with substantial achievements in business and technology has repeatedly attracted controversy over how his achievements in unrelated areas have been presented.

Musk doesn’t need to have been one of the world’s best Quake players to establish that he has a genuine gaming history. He doesn’t need a Path of Exile 2 leaderboard position to establish that he’s accomplished things elsewhere. And he doesn’t need everybody to agree with his political positions to hold them.

Those things can exist independently. Which makes me wonder why recognition so often becomes part of the public conversation.

When Being a Fan Isn’t Enough

I don’t think there’s anything wrong with being proud of your achievements. If somebody completes a difficult challenge in a game, they have every right to celebrate it. And if someone genuinely becomes exceptionally skilled at something, there’s nothing wrong with receiving recognition for that either.

But I do think there’s an important distinction between celebrating an achievement and being clear about how it was obtained. That’s particularly relevant in gaming, where completing a challenge yourself can be the entire point of the experience.

And it brings me back to Dennis Fong’s comments about Musk. Fong didn’t say Musk had no place in the Quake community. He confirmed the opposite. Musk genuinely played the game and participated in that early competitive scene. He was a legitimate gamer. And really, that should be enough.

Then there’s Vivian Jenna Wilson’s recollection of playing Overwatch with him. Even if he was Bronze-ranked, what exactly would have been wrong with that? He was playing a game. He had people to play with. He didn’t need to be a Grandmaster to enjoy himself.

There’s nothing wrong with being an average player, enjoying something you’re not particularly good at, or belonging to a community without needing to stand above everybody else.

I can’t establish whether these incidents share one underlying motive. But what began as an observation about Musk’s recent MAGA comments has left me thinking about something much broader.

Why does being seen as exceptional sometimes seem more important than simply enjoying an activity, participating in a community or being comfortable with what you’ve already achieved? And at what point does the recognition attached to something become more important than the experience itself?

Because you don’t have to be the best to enjoy something. You don’t have to be exceptional to belong.

Sometimes being a fan should be enough.

Sources and Further Reading

The sources below distinguish Musk’s documented statements from reported allegations, third-party recollections and interpretations of his behaviour.

  1. Associated Press — Musk backs away from MAGA after Republicans’ midterm losses
  2. TechCrunch — Elon Musk says: ‘I’m not MAGA’
  3. Lex Fridman Podcast #400 — Elon Musk
  4. PC Gamer — Musk’s Quake claims and Dennis Fong’s recollections
  5. Forbes — Musk’s global top 20 Diablo IV claim
  6. The Guardian — Elon Musk admits cheating at video games, chat transcript appears to show
  7. The Washington Post — Does Elon Musk cheat at video games? An investigation
  8. Teen Vogue — Vivian Jenna Wilson on being Elon Musk’s estranged daughter
  9. PC Gamer — Vivian Wilson responds to Musk’s pro gamer claims
  10. Kotaku — Musk’s reported Cyberpunk 2077 cameo request
  11. PC Gamer — No, that wasn’t Elon Musk in Cyberpunk 2077
  12. Platformer — Yes, Elon Musk created a special system for showing you all his tweets first
  13. ARC Centre of Excellence for Automated Decision-Making and Society — Twitter data and Musk’s reach
  14. Fortune — Musk disputes claims about his posts being boosted
  15. US Securities and Exchange Commission — Tesla Form 8-K, March 2021

Leave a Reply