K/DA is back.
After six years without new music, Riot’s virtual League of Legends group returned in October with FIRESTARTER.
MIYEON and SOYEON returned as Ahri and Akali, roles they have been associated with since POP/STARS in 2018.
Evelynn and Kai’Sa were different.
Mimi Webb took over from Jaira Burns as Kai’Sa, while Canadian singer Sophie Powers became the latest singing voice behind Evelynn.
And judging by some of the reaction I have seen, people have feelings about that.
Particularly Evelynn.
That difference stood out to me almost immediately.
I saw plenty of criticism directed towards Sophie Powers after the new lineup was announced. I personally saw very little of the same reaction towards Mimi Webb.
That does not mean nobody criticised Mimi. In fact, after the Worlds performance there was criticism of both new performers, particularly around dancing and stage presence.
But the reaction I had encountered before that was overwhelmingly centred on Sophie.
And I think that is interesting.
If the problem was simply that Riot had changed two of K/DA’s singers, you might expect both replacements to create roughly the same argument.
They did not.
Most of what I saw was about Evelynn.
Which makes me wonder whether the problem is less about replacing a singer and more about replacing a voice that people had come to associate very strongly with a character.
I have listened to K/DA quite a bit myself over the years.
They were actually one of my most-played artists in one of my Spotify Wrapped results, which probably says quite a lot considering how little music K/DA had released at the time.
I have listened to FIRESTARTER as well.
And I enjoyed it.
So I am not approaching this from the position that the new K/DA is automatically bad because the lineup changed.
My interest in Riot’s world goes beyond K/DA as well.
I have played League of Legends on and off over the years, although these days most of my time with League is through Wild Rift.
I watched Arcane and thoroughly enjoyed that side of the world too.
And every so often I will sit and watch professional League of Legends, even though I am hardly going to pretend I follow every tournament or understand every high-level decision being made on screen.
So while K/DA is what brought me to this particular discussion, the characters and wider League universe are not something I am looking at completely from the outside.
I know the older K/DA songs.
I know what Madison Beer’s Evelynn sounded like.
And when a voice you have heard associated with a character for years suddenly changes, you notice.
Which got me thinking about something slightly bigger than K/DA.
At what point does somebody performing a fictional character become part of the character itself?
Evelynn Was Never Technically Madison Beer
There is an obvious argument in Riot’s favour.
K/DA is a virtual group.
Ahri, Akali, Evelynn and Kai’Sa are the members.
The real-world singers perform alongside those characters rather than literally becoming them.
Madison Beer is not Evelynn in the same way that Evelynn is not Madison Beer.
And Sophie Powers is not actually the first person other than Madison to provide vocals associated with K/DA’s Evelynn.
Destructoid describes Sophie as the fourth voice to portray Evelynn, following performers including Madison Beer, Kim Petras and Bea Miller, alongside Evelynn’s in-game voice performer Mara Junot.
So the idea of different artists embodying the same virtual character is not something Riot invented for FIRESTARTER.
Riot has since explained its approach more directly.
In a November 2026 interview, Riot Games Principal Brand Manager Alex Shahmiri said the artists are considered collaborators with the virtual members. Riot’s intention is not necessarily to permanently replace one singer with another, but to find artists who fit the character’s voice and tone for a particular piece of music while bringing something different themselves.
That makes sense conceptually.
Evelynn remains Evelynn.
Different performers can interpret her.
And Kai’Sa changing performer without initially attracting anything like the same amount of attention, at least from what I personally saw, seems to support the idea that audiences can accept that arrangement.
Except there is a difference between something working conceptually and how an audience actually experiences it.
Madison Beer Became Part Of Evelynn
POP/STARS was where most people first encountered K/DA.
The song arrived in 2018 and turned what could easily have been a one-off League of Legends promotional project into something far larger.
Madison Beer was there as Evelynn.
She returned for MORE.
And VILLAIN became particularly associated with Evelynn’s darker, seductive K/DA persona.
Whether Riot intended it or not, a connection formed.
Madison’s vocal style fitted the version of Evelynn people were seeing and hearing.
Then years passed.
Those songs remained the K/DA material people listened to.
Eventually, for some listeners, it probably stopped feeling like Madison Beer performing Evelynn.
It simply became what Evelynn sounded like.
That is an important difference.
Because once an audience reaches that point, changing the performer becomes much harder than changing a name in the credits.
Perhaps that also helps explain why Sophie attracted such an immediate reaction.
It may not be the fact that somebody was replaced that bothered people.
It may be what they felt had been replaced.
Sophie Powers Does Not Sound Like Madison Beer
And I think this is where some of the reasonable criticism begins.
Sophie Powers sounds different.
That should not be controversial.
Her own musical background leans towards alternative pop and hyperpop, and her interpretation of Evelynn is not simply a recreation of Madison’s.
So when somebody says:
“Sophie Powers can sing, but I don’t think her voice suits Evelynn as well as Madison Beer’s did.”
I do not see anything particularly unreasonable about that.
That is criticism of casting and interpretation.
You can think somebody is a talented singer and still think another performer suited a particular role better.
You can like an actor and still think they were wrong for a character.
You can even enjoy FIRESTARTER, as I did, while still noticing that Evelynn sounds different.
Those positions are not mutually exclusive.
The important part is where that criticism goes next.
Sophie Was Never Trying To Become Madison Beer
Something I find interesting about Sophie is that she seems completely aware of what she walked into.
She was already a K/DA fan.
She listened to Madison Beer.
VILLAIN had been on her playlist.
She was an Arcane fan and had even cosplayed Jinx before becoming involved with Riot.
In an interview with Insider Gaming, Sophie explained that her relationship with Riot began through a Valorant songwriting camp. Riot liked her voice and eventually asked her to audition for Evelynn.
She auditioned.
Riot chose her.
And she then had to work out how to follow somebody whose voice had become strongly associated with the character.
Her response was not to try to become Madison Beer.
When asked by Destructoid about following Evelynn’s previous performers, Sophie said she wanted to create “new shoes” rather than fill somebody else’s.
I think that was probably the right approach.
An attempt to impersonate Madison Beer would have created its own problems.
If Riot is going to use different artists to interpret the same virtual character, those performers need some room to actually interpret the character.
But Different Does Not Automatically Mean Better
That does not mean fans have to like it.
Sophie Powers does not deserve personal abuse because somebody preferred Madison Beer.
But fans are also not obligated to pretend they cannot hear a difference.
They are allowed to prefer the older interpretation.
They are allowed to think Sophie’s voice does not suit Evelynn as well.
They are allowed to listen to FIRESTARTER and decide that this version of K/DA does not work for them.
I enjoyed FIRESTARTER myself.
That does not mean I suddenly cannot understand why somebody else hears Sophie and feels that something about Evelynn has changed.
There is a difference between:
“I don’t think Sophie Powers suits Evelynn.”
And turning that into personal abuse directed at Sophie herself.
One is an opinion about a performance.
The other forgets that Riot made the casting decision.
Sophie Seems To Understand The Nostalgia
This is also something Sophie herself appears to understand.
In that same Insider Gaming interview, she talked openly about the initial negative reaction and compared it to hearing the voice actor of a favourite character being replaced.
That is actually very close to the point I keep coming back to.
She understands why people are attached to the previous voice because she has experienced that sort of attachment herself.
She also said that the response became much more positive after people heard the new music.
That matters too.
The first thing people heard was:
“Madison Beer has been replaced.”
Once the music arrived, there was actually something else to judge.
Madison Apparently Would Have Returned
There is another part of this that makes the reaction easier to understand.
Madison Beer had indicated before FIRESTARTER that she was interested in returning to K/DA.
During her Locket tour, Madison told fans she would love to work with K/DA again, while making clear that the decision was not really hers.
She also said there had apparently been discussions about doing something again a few years earlier, but she did not know what eventually happened to those plans.
Naturally, that leaves people asking why she did not return.
At the moment, there is no public answer that establishes a specific reason.
And this is where I think speculation should stop being presented as fact.
It could have been a creative decision.
Availability could have mattered.
Contracts could have mattered.
Money could have mattered.
Or Riot may simply have wanted a different performer for this version of Evelynn.
Riot’s own explanation is that these artists are collaborators rather than permanent owners of the roles.
Until somebody involved says more than that, anything more specific is guessing.
The Strange Thing About Virtual Characters
K/DA makes this entire discussion unusual because the fictional members obviously cannot perform their own music.
Riot creates the illusion that they can.
Singers, writers, producers, animators, designers and performers combine to create a group whose actual members do not exist.
And yet audiences still develop expectations about how those fictional people should sound.
Evelynn has a personality.
She has a visual identity.
She has a musical identity.
For people who also know her through League of Legends or Wild Rift, K/DA is another version of a character they already recognise.
Eventually a voice can become part of all of that.
That gives Riot enormous freedom.
It can bring different artists into the project without having to replace Evelynn herself.
But it creates a problem as well.
The better a performer fits the character, and the longer audiences associate the two, the more difficult changing that performer becomes.
Technically Replaceable Is Not The Same As Emotionally Replaceable
I think that is probably the heart of this.
Madison Beer was technically replaceable.
Riot owns K/DA.
Evelynn existed before K/DA and continues to exist independently of whichever singer performs her.
But emotionally?
That is different.
People heard Madison on POP/STARS.
They heard her again on MORE.
They associated her with VILLAIN.
Then they spent years listening to those songs without another K/DA release arriving to redefine the character.
At some point repetition becomes identity.
It happens with actors.
It happens with voice actors.
It happens with singers.
A replacement may technically be performing exactly the same character.
To the audience, something has still changed.
Then Came Worlds
K/DA’s return eventually moved from music videos to a physical stage.
At the Worlds 2026 Final opening ceremony, MIYEON, SOYEON, Sophie Powers and Mimi Webb performed as the current K/DA lineup.
That created another round of discussion.
And this is where I need to adjust something from my own earlier impression.
I had mostly encountered backlash towards Sophie.
After Worlds, Mimi Webb was definitely not immune from criticism either.
Fan discussion after the performance criticised elements of the staging, lip-syncing and choreography, while both Sophie and Mimi were compared with MIYEON and SOYEON.
There were also people who felt Sophie had decent stage presence but still did not embody the Evelynn they had in mind.
Others criticised the production more broadly rather than singling out either new singer.
That distinction matters.
It was not simply a case of everyone blaming Sophie for a disappointing performance.
There were several things people disliked about the ceremony.
And comparing the dancing experience of Sophie or Mimi directly with MIYEON and SOYEON also requires some perspective.
MIYEON and SOYEON are experienced K-pop performers.
Sophie had already openly acknowledged before Worlds that she was not a dancer and had been rehearsing heavily for the stage performance.
That does not mean nobody can criticise how she performed.
It just means experience matters when making the comparison.
We See This Everywhere
None of this is unique to K/DA.
Some characters become so strongly associated with one performer that replacing them immediately feels strange.
A cartoon changes voice actor.
A game character gets recast.
A film franchise replaces its lead.
A band changes singer.
Sometimes audiences adapt immediately.
Sometimes the replacement eventually becomes just as strongly associated with the role.
Sometimes people never accept it.
There is no mathematical point where a voice officially becomes inseparable from a character.
It just happens.
Enough time passes.
Enough memorable performances accumulate.
Eventually the audience hears the character before they hear the performer.
For a lot of K/DA fans, that seems to be what happened with Madison Beer and Evelynn.
Riot Has A Difficult Choice
This is ultimately a problem Riot created by making K/DA successful.
And I mean that as a compliment to what they originally built.
If K/DA had been a disposable promotional project, nobody would care very much who performed the next song.
But people became attached to K/DA.
They became attached to individual members.
And they became attached to the performers associated with those members.
That creates expectations around continuity.
MIYEON returning as Ahri reinforces that expectation.
SOYEON returning as Akali reinforces it.
Then Evelynn suddenly sounding different makes the change more noticeable.
Riot’s answer is that these singers are collaborators who embody the characters rather than permanent members attached to them forever.
I actually think that is a reasonable creative approach.
But Riot can control how K/DA is produced.
It cannot control how strongly audiences associate a particular performer with a character.
Give The New Voice A Chance Without Pretending The Old One Did Not Matter
I think that is where I land on Sophie Powers as Evelynn.
I understand why people miss Madison Beer.
Her voice became part of K/DA’s Evelynn for a lot of listeners.
It suited the character, and years without new K/DA music only strengthened that association.
Sophie sounds different.
For some people, perhaps too different.
That is a perfectly reasonable opinion.
But Sophie did not personally remove Madison Beer from K/DA.
She auditioned for a role Riot offered her.
She was already a fan of K/DA.
She knew exactly whose footsteps she was following.
And rather than attempting to recreate Madison Beer, she chose to establish her own version of Evelynn.
I have heard that version now.
I enjoyed FIRESTARTER.
That does not mean Madison’s version suddenly means less to me.
It does not mean everybody else has to prefer Sophie.
It means there is room for me to enjoy what came before while also seeing where Riot takes this version next.
And perhaps that is the strange thing about fictional characters.
The creator owns the character.
But part of that character’s identity eventually belongs to the audience as well.
Riot can decide who performs Evelynn.
It cannot decide what Evelynn sounds like inside somebody else’s head.
Sometimes a performer plays a character for long enough that, to the audience, the voice stops belonging only to the performer.
It becomes the character’s voice.
Sources
- NME — K/DA returns without Madison Beer — reporting on K/DA’s 2026 return, the six-year gap and the FIRESTARTER lineup.
- Destructoid — K/DA Q&A with Sophie Powers — interview covering previous Evelynn performers, Sophie’s approach to the character and the reaction to her casting.
- Insider Gaming — Sophie Powers addresses the reaction to replacing Madison Beer — interview covering her K/DA fandom, Riot audition, Worlds rehearsals and response to criticism.
- Insider Gaming — Riot Games discusses K/DA’s return and changing performers — interview with Riot Principal Brand Manager Alex Shahmiri explaining that performers are treated as collaborators with K/DA’s virtual members rather than permanent replacements.
- DANAMIC — K/DA returns with FIRESTARTER — includes Madison Beer’s comments that she would have liked to return to K/DA and that the decision was not hers.
- LoL Esports — Worlds 2026 Opening Ceremony — Riot’s official listing of the K/DA performers at the 2026 Worlds Final.
- r/kpop — Worlds 2026 K/DA performance discussion — community reaction to the opening ceremony, including discussion of the new performers, choreography and staging.
- League of Legends — K/DA POP/STARS — Riot’s original 2018 K/DA release featuring MIYEON, SOYEON, Madison Beer and Jaira Burns.